Ten Years On, and Still Fighting the Same Battles
Nearly ten years ago, I challenged Leeds City Council through judicial review proceedings over its proposal to reduce specialist post-16 education from five days a week to three.
My daughter has profound learning disabilities and complex medical needs. Her education was about far more than sitting in a classroom. It was about communication, independence, relationships and developing skills that had taken years to achieve.
With the support of the Public Law Project, I challenged the decision. The council eventually conceded before the case reached a full court hearing, and my daughter’s five-day provision was protected.
I remember thinking we’d achieved something important. Not just for my daughter, but for other disabled young people and their families.
What I didn’t realise was that almost a decade later, we’d still be fighting the same battles.
Different governments, different departments, different policies, but the same relentless struggle to secure support that disabled people need.
Now it’s PIP reform, reassessments and proposed restrictions to SEND transport. Tomorrow it will be something else. There always seems to be another consultation, another proposed saving, another change to eligibility and another argument about what disabled people cost.
I understand that public money has to be managed. But why does the conversation so often begin with what can be taken away rather than what people actually need?
A child who cannot travel independently doesn’t suddenly become capable of catching a bus because a council needs to save money. A person with a lifelong genetic condition doesn’t become less disabled because eligibility criteria change. And when support is reduced, the need doesn’t disappear. The responsibility simply lands somewhere else, usually with families who are already doing everything they can. That’s the part that rarely seems to feature in the calculations.
I’ve spent almost 24 years caring for my daughter. I’ve fought for education, healthcare, social care, communication support and basic dignity. I’ve attended countless meetings, tribunals, challenged decisions, written complaints and spent years trying to get services to deliver what they’ve already agreed she needs.
When she left education, the battles didn’t stop. They simply moved into adult services.
She has had NHS Continuing Healthcare funding since 2021, yet securing reliable care has been another exhausting struggle. ICB in West Yorkshire delegate to social care and social care treat the package as just another social package - thinking inexperienced carers suffice for someone so complex.
Meanwhile, I’m facing a heart transplant.
My transplant team wants to list me, but I’ve had to explain that I cannot safely proceed until my daughter’s care arrangements are secure.
I sometimes wonder whether the people making decisions about disability support understand what years of fighting actually do to a family.
It’s not just the individual decision or the latest proposed cut. It’s the cumulative effect of never being able to relax, of constantly having to prove needs that haven’t changed, and of knowing that even when you win one battle, another is probably waiting around the corner.
I think back to that judicial review and wonder what we actually learned.
We successfully challenged a decision affecting my daughter’s education. Yet nearly ten years later, disabled people and their families are still having to defend the support they depend upon. And I worry about the families who don’t have the knowledge, energy or resources to challenge decisions. Those who simply accept what’s offered because they’re too exhausted to fight any longer. Because that’s what this endless cycle risks doing. Wearing people down until they stop challenging it.
Disability doesn’t disappear when budgets are cut. The need for support doesn’t vanish because politicians want to reduce expenditure. And unpaid carers cannot continue absorbing every gap in provision indefinitely (1 in 3 unpaid carers care over 100 hours a week).
I don’t expect unlimited resources. I expect some recognition that disabled people have needs that cannot simply be reduced to a financial target, and that families should not have to spend their lives fighting to have those needs recognised. Almost ten years ago, I thought winning our judicial review might mean something had changed.
Instead, the arguments have continued, the cuts and proposed restrictions keep coming, and the responsibility for fighting them still falls on the same families. Perhaps that’s the cruellest part of all. After years of fighting, you begin to wonder whether the system is designed to help disabled people at all, or whether the endless assessments, challenges, delays and threats of cuts simply wear families down until they have nothing left to give. Because that is what it does. It leaves you utterly exhausted, demoralised and frightened about what comes next. Not because your child’s disability has suddenly become harder to live with, but because the systems supposedly there to support them have made life so relentlessly difficult. And when you’ve spent almost a quarter of a century fighting for your child’s rights, only to find yourself seriously ill and still having to beg for the most basic support, you do start to wonder whether wearing families down is no longer an unfortunate consequence of the system, but simply how it works.
Our original legal challenge was supported by the Public Law Project. You can read about it here: PLP’s client wins fight for education.
Comments